In “Checks and Balances’” (as I will now refer to her as because I can’t find her name, and I apologize) blog post, she addresses some of the issues concerning illegal immigration.
First, she points out that Arizona has decided to act on its own because it is tired of waiting for the Federal Government to enforce the current laws and in return the President has decided to sue them.
-I feel a bit of background would help to show what specifically Arizona has done and what the current laws that the Federal Government, Checks and Balances states, have failed to enforce are. The law pertaining to illegal immigrants is that anyone over the age of 14 who has been in the US for more than 30 days is required to register with the US government and must carry that registration with them at all times. Arizona furthered the law in their state with the passage of the Support Our Law Enforcement and Safe Neighborhoods Act, also known as the Arizona Senate Bill 1070, which enforces the Federal law by stating that it is a crime to be in Arizona without those registration documents.
Another thing she mentions is what an immigrant is.
-Just to clarify, it is not immigrants that are the cause of concern. It is illegal immigrants. There is a huge difference as we are all “immigrants”, if you will, and I’m sure illegal immigrants are who she was referring to.
Checks and Balances mentions “broken laws and risk to Americans”, but does not name any.
-One of the arguments regarding illegal immigrants is whether their influence on the economy is good or bad. Some find it beneficial in that it allows struggling companies to stay alive by hiring the immigrants for a very low wage. Others argue that it hurts the economy by taking away prospective jobs from US citizens. Also dealing with the economy, there is the view that the money the immigrants make is returned to society by buying food, clothes, furniture..etc, while others say that it would help if 100% of the profit were to be returned to society but a good percentage of their income goes to their families in their native country. There are other debates, such as crime statistics, but those were just a few regarding the different views.
Another point she brings out is that states should have the right to decide how to handle local issues like this.
-I agree, as each state is affected by different issues on different levels. Immigration is a federal issue, and each state has its own authority to enforce and regulate certain laws in order to protect its citizens.
According to her last paragraph, Checks and Balances is concerned about the border security.
-The problem does not lie predominantly with the borders as most people think, to borrow Mr. Perry’s famous little quote “we need boots on the ground” haha. Yes, illegal immigrants do “sneak” across the border, but the majority of illegal immigrants in the US enter legally. The issue is they do not follow the law in registering after the 30 days.
I understand where Checks and Balances is coming from. She is rightfully upset about illegal immigration and its affect on the American society. Even though I agree with her stance, I feel presenting more facts would help her view come across more effectively.