The commentary here is a conversation between two adults, one male (David), an Op-Ed columnist for the NYT since 2003, and one female (Gail), an Op-Ed columnist for the NYT since 1995. Gail feels that the current presidency debate is focused more on women issues than on things you would expect, such as jobs. The argument seems to be that the ever existing debate about certain things pertaining to women such as abortion and contraception are being overly focused on in the GOP debates and that Santorum is either using the current contraception debate as part of a good for his campaign or if he as a religious person feels so strongly about it he can’t help but bring the topic up. The conversation continues on regarding women, marriage, children and whether the order of their occurrence affects the traditional family. The argument David makes is that low-income women tend to view marriage as a reward and children as a necessity is backwards in comparison to women who viewed marriage as part of the upward climb and the children came after. The result is “people who marry before childbearing, graduate from high school and get a job, any job, do not live in poverty”. He feels that Obama should start a campaign that says people should get married before they have kids.
A few points I noticed here that I don’t feel were supported by facts are:
David stated, “Free market beliefs and socially conservative beliefs require each other, so long as those socially conservative beliefs are traditional, not theological. I’m for traditional values, with government playing a small role to support them. I get worried when some politician begins trying to legislate his faith’s version of Natural Law.”
- Don't tradition and theology, or religious background beliefs, kind of go hand in hand? I'd say a good percentage of traditional stems from some sort of theological ideal. So, in supporting a traditional belief, one is in essence supporting an idea that was based on a theological belief that overtime became a tradition, without acknowledging it as theological. This is not true in every case, but for the majority, I would say, yes.
Gail at one point said: "Now the debate is about things like contraception, fertilization treatments and prenatal testing. A vast majority of Americans don't regard any of these things as immoral."
- My question is what statistic is she basing the "vast majority" on? Twenty-three percent of Americans are Catholic. That is a large percent, almost 1/4 who just by religious affiliation think that contraception is wrong. Catholics are not the only ones who believe this, but knowing that at least twenty-three percent believe this, automatically refutes the idea that the "vast majority" don't think its immoral.
One argument I might have made in the conversation about the order of marriage and children is, how would one not have enough money for a wedding, yet think they can afford to have a kid?
The commentary seems to be focued around the general public, more so towards those who care about the GOP debates and the topics being focused on. I think a few more facts and examples would have helped in the convincing of the arguments.
- Don't tradition and theology, or religious background beliefs, kind of go hand in hand? I'd say a good percentage of traditional stems from some sort of theological ideal. So, in supporting a traditional belief, one is in essence supporting an idea that was based on a theological belief that overtime became a tradition, without acknowledging it as theological. This is not true in every case, but for the majority, I would say, yes.
Gail at one point said: "Now the debate is about things like contraception, fertilization treatments and prenatal testing. A vast majority of Americans don't regard any of these things as immoral."
- My question is what statistic is she basing the "vast majority" on? Twenty-three percent of Americans are Catholic. That is a large percent, almost 1/4 who just by religious affiliation think that contraception is wrong. Catholics are not the only ones who believe this, but knowing that at least twenty-three percent believe this, automatically refutes the idea that the "vast majority" don't think its immoral.
One argument I might have made in the conversation about the order of marriage and children is, how would one not have enough money for a wedding, yet think they can afford to have a kid?
The commentary seems to be focued around the general public, more so towards those who care about the GOP debates and the topics being focused on. I think a few more facts and examples would have helped in the convincing of the arguments.