In Lee Bailey Bradshaw’s Blog Post , Ms. Bradshaw gives her view on why Canada’s healthcare system is not America’s answer.
First lets look at some of the main characteristics of Canada’s healthcare system. Their system in general is supposed to be a mix of a public-private system, where the private sector gives healthcare services and the public is responsible for financing the services. Even though this is the way it is supposed to be, the government actually has a large authority over the services given by the private sector. The private sector does have their role, but the government exercises more authority than the private sector is given. Another element of this system is that it is not a single national system. The country is divided into 10 provinces, each of which are responsible for making their own laws regarding healthcare. The federal government plays its part by spending tens of billions of dollars annually in the healthcare area. At any time the federal government can choose to withdraw its financial support. This allows the federal government to set its own rules for the provinces to follow in order to receive this financial support. These requirements are that all provincial systems be publicly administered, comprehensive, universal, portable and accessible.
With that general overview, lets take a look at Ms. Bradshaw’s arguments against this system. Her first argument is that the increased numbers of health care services would lead to longer lines.
- This argument is valid and can be backed by facts. The Health Council of Canada did a survey regarding wait times in Canada vs. the US. In every single instance, Canadians had a substantially longer wait.
Her second argument is that there would be less quality doctors.
- Americans have access to better quality, while all Canadians have access to the same care but at a lower cost. The reasoning for the lower cost is that there is a restriction of supply with sub-optimal access to services.
Her last argument is that there would be an overall decline in the efficiency of our medical services.
- I agree with this premise. If healthcare were to become public rather than privatized, what point would there be for doctors to pursue this degree. I understand a doctor’s first code is provide the necessary services and they are compassionate humans, but being honest, if doctor’s pay were decreased and hours increased, not many doctors will “stick around”. I myself am going into a medical field for two reasons: 1) because I like to know that I’m making a difference in someone’s life but 2) because it pays well. My decision to choose this career path includes both of those reasonings. One by itself would prompt me to look at other options. Just being realistic, I do not believe a good percentage of current doctor’s would have pursued this field if they though the outcome would be like Canada’s.
Overall, I believe Ms. Bradshaw makes some valid points that can be backed by facts. There are many more factors, both good and bad, that can be taken into consideration on this topic, but she covered some of the main ones that most citizens would be concerned with in healthcare services provided.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.